Showing posts with label blog 3. Show all posts
Showing posts with label blog 3. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

The Allegory of the Cave (9/20)

Today we will
  • Pre-write and watch a video to get ready for a hard reading.
  • Read and annotate "The Allegory of the Cave," a ENG101-style reading.
  • Put together a summary of the main ideas of "The Allegory of the Cave."
  • Connect the symbols in the story with literal meanings.
  • Give feedback to Dr. Smith's class, "Living in the Matrix," for their group summaries of "Is Google...?"
A. PRE-WRITING and VIDEO
Please answer the questions below on a piece of paper. Be prepared to share your ideas with the class.
  1. The piece we are about to read and discuss, “The Allegory of the Cave,” is an important example of Ancient Greek philosophy. In Greek, “philosophy” literally means “love of wisdom.” But what is wisdom? What do you think? Why do you think people study philosophy?
  2. An allegory is a story with two meanings, a literal meaning and a symbolic meaning, where the symbolic meaning serves as a mirror of the real problem or question. This allegory is about a cave. What do you know about caves? What could a cave represent? What could the phrase “to be in a cave” mean? What could the phrase “come out of the cave” mean?
  3. Watch this adaptation of Plato's text:




B. ANNOTATING “THE ALLEGORY OF THE CAVE”

Socrates, from Wikipedia
Context for the reading: The author of “The Allegory of the Cave,” Plato, lived in Athens about 2,400 years ago. He was the student of another outstanding Athenian philosopher, Socrates. In “The Allegory of the Cave,” Socrates is speaking, and it is he who invents an allegory to help one of his students, Glaucon, understand a complex philosophical idea.

The reading is on pages 22-24 of the class packet. We will read the piece out loud, stopping to make clarifications, answer questions, and stress important ideas.

Then you will read the piece again and annotate the reading to your satisfaction. Please consult your dictionaries for any words you do not understand.

C. SUMMARIZING THE STORY
Click on the scrambled summary of "The Allegory of the Cave" HERE. Figure out what is the correct order and submit your answer as a list of numbers separated by commas (Example: 3,1, 7, 5, 12, etc.) in the Google Forms below.




Answers HERE.

D. THINKING CRITICALLY about SYMBOLS
Working in groups of three, match each symbolic element of the story with its philosophic meaning HERE. Be prepared to share your answers with the class.

E. GIVING FEEDBACK ON SUMMARY
Follow the link HERE. I will assign you a group from Dr. Smith's class. Please evaluate their responses by answering the following questions and then typing your response below their post in the Google Doc (using another color font would help for them to see it). Be nice but also be honest!
  1. What has the group done well in the their summary?
  2. What could the group do to improve their summary or what would you have done differently and why? 
HOMEWORK
Blog 3: In your blog, write 2-3 paragraphs that summarize the philosophic meaning of Socrates’ story—what is he trying to explain to Glaucon about the meaning of life? Follow this introduction:
In Plato’s “The Allegory of the Cave,” Socrates tells a story to his student Glaucon to explain ...

Monday, March 14, 2011

Homework for Wednesday (3/16)

YES, you do have lab on Wednesday--please be on time.

To do for homework--due Wednesday at 5:45:

1.  On your own, summarize "I Know the Truth, so Don't Bother Me with Facts" on page 12 of the packet in a MSWord document, then copy and paste it into the Google Docs below. Sign the summary with your name or alias (depending).
Google Docs: Individual Summaries of "I Know the Truth, so Don't Bother Me with Facts."
2. From the document above,

Superman reviews Linda
Linda reviews Tiffany
Tiffany reviews Alice
Alice reviews 007
007 reviews Confused
Confused reviews Topacio
Topacio reviews Baris
Baris reviews VI
VI reviews Agata
Agata reviews Tyler's Mom
Tyler's Mom reviews Artemis
Artemis reviews Eliott
Elliot reviews Tapon
Tapon reviews Jorge
Jorge reviews Superman

How to review: Write three comments in a MSWord document answering the questions below. Copy and paste your answers UNDER the summary you were reviewing.
  • What is one thing that I really liked in this summary?
  • What is one thing I found confusing , needed more explanation, etc?
  • If this were my summary, what is one thing I would change?
3. After reviewing the comments for your summary, go to your blog and create Blog 3: Reflecting on Summary. In this blog entry, please answer the following questions:
  • What have you learned from the Summarizing class?
  • How do you know that you have learned it?
  • Can you describe how you learned it?
  • What helped your learning? What made it difficult?
  • How do you feel after today's class?

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Summarizing (3/14)

To Do:
Get together with the members of your group, give yourselves a nifty name, and designate one member as the group's typist.

Group 1:  Julio, Jihyun, Linda
Group 2: Rebekah, Eliott, Diana
Group 3: Joao, Chanda, Baris
Group 4: Agata, Jorge, Carolina
Group 5: Lisa, , Julie, Jennifer

***
Today we will:
  • Think critically about Summarizing
  • Review a sample summary of a CAT reading
  • Work in groups to summarize a second CAT reading
  • Work individually to summarize a third CAT reading

I. Thinking Critically about Summary
  1. On your own, take a few minutes to write down what the word "summary" means to you.
  2. In your group, read the original text and the four versions of it in the document "Four Takes on One Text" below. Decide which of the four versions is a summary of the original text and why. If you have time left, describe what the other three versions are doing to the original text. Be prepared to share your answers with the class.
Four Takes on One Text
II. Summarizing
  1. On your own, review "Summarizing" on page 2 of your packet. Now discuss with your group: Which of the ideas makes sense to you? Which do not? Why? Which do you think you could use when you are writing? Why?
  2. On your own, read the sample CAT reading "How to Do One Thing at a Time" on page 9 of the class packet and then read the summary HERE. Now discuss with your group: What in the summary makes sense to you? What would you do differently? Why?
  3. With your group, summarize the sample CAT reading "Is Google Making Us Stupid?" on page 11 of the packet in a MSWord document. Once the group is satisfied with the summary, copy and paste it into the Google Docs below. Sign the summary with your nifty group name.
Google Docs: Group Summary of "Is Google Making Us Stupid?"

4. On your own, summarize "I Know the Truth, so Don't Bother Me with Facts" on page 12 of the packet in a MSWord document, then copy and paste it into the Google Docs below. Sign the summary if you wish.
Google Docs: Individual Summaries of "I Know the Truth, so Don't Bother Me with Facts."
5. From the document above, I will assign you a summary (not your own) to review. For it, write three comments in a MSWord document answering the questions below. Copy and paste your answers UNDER the summary you were reviewing.
  • What is one thing that I really liked in this summary?
  • What is one thing I found confusing , needed more explanation, etc?
  • If this were my summary, what is one thing I would change?
6. After reviewing the comments for your summary, go to your blog and create Blog 3: Reflecting on Summary. In this blog entry, please answer the following questions:
  • What have you learned from class today?
  • How do you know that you have learned it?
  • Can you describe how you learned it?
  • What helped your learning? What made it difficult?
  • How do you feel after today's class?

Monday, September 20, 2010

Homework for Thursday Sept 23

  • Use the voting gadget on the top right to choose the best of the Group Summaries below. Take into consideration all that we learned today from reading pages 5-8 of the packet when you are voting.
  • Use the Comments section for THIS blog post to rectify any summaries that you think need revision to be accurate
  • In your own blog, write Blog 3: " Things I Need to Remember When I Write Summaries."

Group Summaries (of paragraphs in pages 7-8 of packet)

The Duo
Summary of Paragraph 2: Telling the truth during a social relationship is expected for social harmony.

Black and White
Summary of Paragraph 6: Americans do not agree with Latin’s habit of drinking with their meals.

The Fab Three
Summary of Paragraph 5: From “Why We Buy”. Paco Underhill, write part of being Daddy is being the provider so it is not a good idea to send the men to go shopping because men don’t really know what to buy.

M.A.B.
Summary of Paragraph 5: Women are more organized than men when it comes to shopping, because according to the passage “ he’s notoriously bad at saying no when there’s grocery acquisitioning”.

Passive
Summary of Paragraph 3: Glenn C. Altsculer: states that professors use new ways to entertain students while teaching.

The Views
Summary of Paragraph 2: Its not best to tell someone the truth because it can “destroy social relationships”